BIONICLE G2 I find difficult to rank as a whole. I would give the sets an 8/10 and the story a 3/10. I guess if I average those together I get a 5.5/10...? I'll round that down instead of up because I feel like it, so I'll give it a 5/10. Not terrible, not great, just flat average.
Hero Factory I'd give a 6.5/10 for the sets and a 4 for its story, so a 5.25 as an overall product. Still very simplistic but I felt that HF didn't take itself too seriously which made for some legitimately entertaining pieces of content like Hero Factory FM. Additionally, it ran for over twice as long as G2, so it was able to flesh out its world and characters more.
G1 gets a 9/10 for set design and an 8/10 for story, so an 8.5/10 overall. Neither were perfect, but while G2 perfected the "Matoran" and Toa designs, G1 had killer titans, vehicles, and Rahi which G2 simply never had. Additionally, the story was of a much higher caliber, though it's not perfect due to questionable plot choices, dropped story elements, and its convoluted nature.
Star Wars constraction I'll give a 7/10. A lot of the sets are fairly standard humanoid fare, but they're huge, well armored, and some of them feature innovative torso designs that incorporate the G2 gearbox in a much more fulfilling way. Plus, SW Constraction has given us Grievous which is better than anything G2 gave us Titan-wise so it gets bonus points for that.
Chima constraction gets... a 6.5/10. A lot of the sets were somewhat standard, but a ton of cool new recolors were introduced, and a few creative building techniques were utilized a long the way. Plus, I think they did a fairly good job of adapting the Chima characters to the constraction style, unlike this next one...
Super Heroes constraction gets a 3/10. Good effort, but most of the sets were just... lackluster. Their heads looked unsettling, their builds were very simplistic due to CCBS being in its early stages, and there were really only two memorable sets from the entire wave (Iron Man and Joker), neither of which I would call masterpieces. Iron Man was pretty good, though.
Pretty sure that I'm not.
Nope! They're on my list, though.