I feel like you're trying to lead me to somethig, that I don't get. I can however provide a list.
Carolina (RVB): Emotionally scarred
Pyrrha (RWBY): Dead
Penny (RWBY): Dead
Roman Torchwhick (RWBY): Dead
David (Camp Camp): Seriously emotionally troubled
They all have one unifying trait. Red hair, and Green eyes. I really hope Skout breaks the treand.