My order would be:
1: Infinity War-Perfect movie to me.
2: Spiderverse- great story, visually mindblowing
3: Bumblebee- Finally a great transformers movie! Great visual style, heartwarming, nostalgic
4: Fallout- Superb action
5: A Quiet Place- JIM!!! Great concept, directing, and performances
6: Aquaman- A heck of a lot of fun. Superb costuming, visuals, and cinematography, but pacing felt crazy and the plot was... solid but derivative.
7:Incredibles 2- Visuslly awesome, nostalgic, funny, but strangely forgetful to a degree
8: Ant Man and the Wasp- Hilarious, good action, I just sunjectively like a lot of the other movies better
9: Black Panther- I really wanted this to be higher. Great story, but it felt like they dropped the ball a tad on some of the action and visuals. I wish the action was more Russo-esque. Still a really good movie, though.
10: Solo- Just... decent. I like it, but Han felt off most of the time. He was too awkward, I think. The droid was kind of annoying, but not overly so.
I’d put The Death of Superman in there somewhere, but it wasnt in theatres. It was good.
If you hadn’t noticed, I’m a sucker for action and visuals. Some of these are iffy enough I might be persuaded to shift them around. Pretty much everything from 4-8 is about the same rank, within a few decimal points.