Lets analyse some of these points and counterpoints;
People can want originality in something while liking others. Your counterpoint simply doesnt work here. The point is that they would prefer an original product when it comes to Lego. Whether they liked Avengers, Batman, Star Wars or anything else simply does not matter. This is a valid reason for why people do not want a G3, as they want Lego to create an entirely new original independent property instead and a G3 Bionicle would hurt chances of a new CCBS theme being made.
Basing future prospects of the previous itteration is natural and to be expected. In this case this is a valid reason to be worried about G3. We've seen two examples of Bionicle so far, and the most recent example, the example more likely to represent modern day is that. Your counterpoint doesnt work here because its simply ignoring the past and most likely example of how the theme would be handled if a return happened.
I kind of see what you are saying here, however while there is the potential for Bionicle to return, there is no concrete proof that it will. Your counterpoint doesnt support a G3 either and the comment itself is not a remark on whether people want G3, but more a remark on their doubt of the line returning at all.
- Two of these points are valid remarks on why someone would'nt want a G3
- One of these points is not about people not wanting G3