Wow. That was even more people than I thought.
That one (Where's God when I'm S-s-scared?) was one of the very first ones I owned (alongside Are You My Neighbor?) I think we had given it away because it legitimately frightened me, but I eventually wanted to watch it again so we got a new copy.
I remember hearing this. It was cool.
For me it was the Fib from Outer Space episode. (I'm sensing a pattern here...)