I’m a little afraid to post this, but it’s been on my mind for some time now. So the primary focus of TTV is Bionicle. The TTV people let us post about other Lego themes on these boards, and they even have forums for non-Lego related stuff, but most of what I see on here is Bionicle-related.
Do I have anything against that? Absolutely not. Bionicle was a big part of my childhood. I drew pictures of Bionicle characters. I read the comic books that came free with every Lego magazine. I spent significant portions of my free time poking around the Bionicle website, playing the games and reading up on the stories and characters. And, of course, I collected the sets. I got a pretty respectable amount from the 2007-2010 era, and even though they’re all in pieces due to the parts breaking, I still have my tub of Bionicle parts. I may not have gotten up in arms when G2 came around, but in the years since, I’ve regretted not getting more of the sets. From what I’ve seen, many of them were pretty solid. I’ve gone back and revisited Bionicle media in the past couple years, and I still find enjoyment in it.
But no matter what I do, a fact remains that I cannot escape. G1 ended ten years ago, and G2 failed so bad, it didn’t even get a third year. And Lego is showing no signs of reviving Bionicle, or any kind of constraction. Even though it’s sad to see constraction go, I enjoy seeing their other themes, such as Ninjago, Hidden Side, Monkie Kid, and Nexo Knights (fight me).
Of course, nothing seems to be capable of stopping the Bionicle fanbase. We’ve still chugged along, sharing MOCs and writing fanfics. Even though Sokoda’s Ideas project didn’t get approved, we were still able to band together and show Lego that we still care. And the G1 canonization contests have brought out some really good MOCs.
But what I’m wondering is…what are we doing this for?
The reason why I’m feeling these feelings is because of stuff I’ve seen on these boards. I’ve seen people make claims that Lego doesn’t care about Bionicle, and that everyone who worked on G1 has left the company (sans Greg). One post even said that Greg “doesn’t care as much as you do.” Some people have even criticized the G1 canonization contests, saying that we’re getting all up in arms about a line that’s ten years old, and that we should find better things to do with our time.
Watching people argue isn’t the most fun way to spend my time. But I can’t help wondering…what if those people are right? Sure, Bionicle was unique, but it was, at its core, a Lego theme. Plenty of Lego themes-Exo-Force, Power Miners, Space Police, Adventurers-have came and gone over the years, but you don’t see that many people obsessing over those or yelling at Lego to bring them back, do you? And if Lego no longer cares about Bionicle or constraction in general, then it’s likely that we’ll never see it again.
I’m not saying it’s bad to be nostalgic. What I’m saying is…maybe it is pointless to make more Bionicle Ideas sets. Maybe it is pointless to do these G1 canonization contests. I hate to admit it, but given what I’ve seen, I don’t think Greg really has his heart in canonizing these MOCs. His attitude seems to be “Eh, whatever.” And maybe it is pointless to keep making these two-hour+ YouTube videos about a Lego line that’s dead. It just seems like a lot. Especially because lots of people that liked Bionicle back in the day seem to have moved on and forgotten about it.
On the whole, I’m just not sure how to feel about this. I’ve always been a nostalgic person, so I understand the Bionicle community’s devotion to the theme that did so much for them back in the day. But at the same time, the people on these boards that emphasize Lego having no reason to do anything new with Bionicle have a point. Wise people like to say that, if you get too caught up in the past, then you’ll never have a future. And maybe that’s what’s happening here. Maybe we’re so fixated on G1, we’re blind to whatever new and cool stuff Lego might roll out. And to that end, I’m somewhat ashamed to be part of the Bionicle community.
[takes a deep breath] There. It felt good to get that off my chest.