To quote Greg’s word on that,
2 Likes
So this basically means the only chance we have to know what the regular version was is the Naho contest. Or a random background Matoran from the comics
1 Like
but, keep in mind that, it is highly likely that Naho is not from Metru nui
This only suggests that Naho’s Huna may be noble design or variant.
It can be hard to say that it’s a standard design.
2 Likes
Yeah good point. Maybe we could have a Mask contest then for masks that are likely to never be in a canonization contest, like the Noble Avokii and the Hagah Masks. That way we wouldn’t have to have multiple contests for unnecessary characters, but still know what the masks look like
So
Noble:
- Hau (Metru)
- KauKau
- Pakari
- Kadin
- Avokii
Great:
- Kiril (Only if there’s no contest)
- Hagah Masks (powers not the shapes we currently have)
- Huna (Metru)
Personally I think it would be better if it was 6 masks, with all Noble (Except which ever Turaga is chosen for the second round of contests) and the Huna.
1 Like
Just got the parts in for Lhikan, and I’m now ready for the tuyet contest
13 Likes
The cape you’ve added has me thinking.
How would people feel about an option to designate their entries by type of Tuyet? Kind of like the consent system for the Toa Hagah, this would be a way for entrants to designate which version of Tuyet they’d like to cater their entry toward. When we send the winning entry to Greg, we’d specify that it’s for the canon appearance of (blank) version of Tuyet. This wouldn’t result in individual polls, it’d still be for a single winning entry.
As an example:
ENTRY INTENDED TO BE:
-Prime Universe Tuyet
-Dark Mirror Tuyet
-Both
Not something we’ve discussed at length, just tossing the thought out there and see what you all think about it.
19 Likes
Did Tuyet have a substantially different appearance in Dark Mirror? I don’t think I’d be too interested even if she did–supposing a Dark Mirror Tuyet MOC won, we’d never really know what Prime Universe Tuyet looked like, which… kinda hamstrings a large part of the contest’s purpose, in my opinion.
3 Likes
That’s the big question, really. The compromise the thought attempts to be for is for those that feel that Tuyet does look different in Dark Mirror than she does normally. In StudentScissors current version, Tuyet bears a cape and dark, spikey armor - I’m certain that’s meant to evoke a particular atmosphere that many wouldn’t readily associate with a Prime Universe Toa.
Again, nothing we’re actively considering, just curious what people think about the concept.
7 Likes
I think that’s a really, really good idea, if nothing else than to appease the most people and prevent the most conflict.
4 Likes
I s’pose if the question is just left open, yeah, we may as well have people submit what they think is the most iconic Tuyet version, whether or not Dark Mirror looks different from Prime Universe.
1 Like
I don’t like this idea.
To me, Prime Tuyet is far more important than Dark Mirror Tuyet, and the prime universe should be the focus of these contests.
However, that’s not my biggest problem with the idea; even if people disagree with me and would rather see Dark Mirror Tuyet, then whatever, but then that should be known from the start of the contest. It makes no sense to me to not even know what character is being canonized until the contest is over.
Here’s another idea: you said you wouldn’t do a separate contest for each version, but have you considered just doing two art contests? One would have to follow the MOC winner exactly (or at least as exactly as the past art entrants have) and be Prime Tuyet, while the other could take more extreme liberties and be Dark Mirror Tuyet.
The only issue with this is that it would require a separate Mask Contest to ensure that both versions at least have the same mask.
Again, I’m open to the idea of canonizing Dark Mirror Tuyet rather than Prime Tuyet (though I still disagree with it), but it should absolutely be made clear which version the contest is for before it starts.
11 Likes
That might be the better outcome.
Think about the biggest complaint against these contests: they stifle creativity, by giving only one appearance to a character. But if a black, spiky DMT like Student’s wins, people can make a “good” PT based on the canon model; conversely, if a heroic-looking PT wins, people can moc a dark, spiky DMT based on the canon model.
I wouldn’t mind if a Tuyet with the Nui Stone fragments was allowed under this, too. So basically there’d be three versions (though one would be mutually exclusive from the other two)
1 Like
I believe that the characters Takanuva met on his journey through the multiverse were variants. That’s how DC and Marvel are handling things, so why not us?
ALSO
I REALLY LIKE THIS IDEA.
This should be done for Tuyet from Dark Mirror, Toa Macku from The Melding, Toa Tanma from The Kingdom, the Kestora from the core dimension (so they can look different from those in City of Silver pocket dimension), etc.
2 Likes
Technically, there’s a third tuyet: the dead doppleganger who maybe helped Hydraxon when the pit fell. But having us only have a picture for her would be (and I’m going to use technical lore-analysis language here) dumb.
I’d say I’m of two minds on making the creator specify which one. On one hand, it simplifies the issue on BS01 of “which Tuyet is this a picture of?”. On the other hand…we’ve had this debate, I don’t want to reawaken it, but we have absolutely every reason to believe tuyet looks the same accross universes.
Compromise proposal: specify which tuyet it is at the art portion, and allow for “undefined” to be an option. This basically means you’d be taking the tuyet “set”, and depicting it doing evil dark mirrory things, or prime universy things, similar to how characters with other AU counterparts were used (if that makes sense).
Second compromise proposal: two poll sets, two winners at the art portion: one for Tuyet Prime, one for Mirror Tuyet. This would give us both versions of the art that we may want, while also not making Mirror Tuyet compete against Tuyet Prime. This creates the complication of “how do we make their kanohi match”, but I’m sure there’s a solution.
EDIT: possible solution to proposal two might be do prime art contest first, then dark mirror contest, but even though the results on that long-term will be great in my opinion, there may be pushback.
EDIT 2: I shouldn’t have just skimmed the thread, Jerminator came up with this idea before me, I swear I wasn’t just plagarising.
4 Likes
Just mandate prime Tuyet then. That’s the one we should be canonizing. Those who want to make a darker evil Tuyet based on the moc/art, can still do so, but this contest should be canonizing the prime Tuyet.
The problem is that we’d be canonizing that there is a difference, which as you pointed out, currently has no canonical basis.
2 Likes
Personally, I agree. That being the case, for your consideration:
Entered Tuyet is Prime Universe Tuyet by default. Option for entrants to either suggest it for Dark Mirror as well, or only as Prime?
Personally, I feel like these complicate things more than anything else.
At the end of the day, the easiest solution would be to just focus on Prime Universe and leave it there. This is only serving to act as a compromise for those that feel “evil-looking” Tuyet’s may not be befitting of the Prime Universe. That said, this may be a case of trying to cater to a specific outcome before voters have their say, which should be avoided if possible.
2 Likes
A lot of people feel that prime Tuyet should look dark and villainous; others feel she should look more heroic. I don’t care for villainous Tuyet, but I’d prefer it over only having a villainous appearance for Dark Mirror Tuyet and nothing for prime.
3 Likes
I agree that I personally want Prime Universe characters primarily, and that the focus in the contests should be there (we didn’t have a contest for mirror Kualus and Bomonga, for example).
I do think, though, that Tuyet is an extraordinary case with few other examples. Her AU counterpart has a bit of an iconic status, which leads to two competing problems:
1: Passing up on an opportunity to depict her in her mirror form feels like a wasted opportunity
2: Passing up on an opportunity to depict her in her prime form feels like a wasted opportunity.
I do think there’s space here for some kinda super artistic art that integrates parts of Prime Tuyet and Mirror Tuyet, but I cannot imagine many people will make something like that.
Again, I am unsure off the top of my head of any other character this is true for (I mean, actually, that’s not true, it’s true of Teridax, but we DID end up getting a visual depiction for his light version). Unless anyone can think of a character who’s contest may call for two different results, Tuyet is an unusual case that will not repeat. It may not hurt to treat her as such.
4 Likes
This might be the best option. Allow voters to establish that they’re the same, or leave it open that Farm Mirror could be different, but not writing new canon by canonically establish that they’re different.
Edit
Thank you autocorrect.
2 Likes
This Tuyet wasn’t really super relevant to the story; she likely wouldn’t qualify for these contests on her own.
Besides, unlike other alternate Tuyets, we already know for sure that she looks like Prime Tuyet (otherwise the duplicate plot wouldn’t have worked), so her appearance will be decided with Prime Tuyet’s.
We could, but that would be more of trivia canonization than appearance canonization.
We’d also run into the issue where people vote for the relation to Dark Mirror Tuyet, rather than the appearance itself.
2 Likes