This is more of a general thing, though I feel it may still belong here: how do other people feel about in-character sign-up sheets? By this I mean sign-up sheets that exist within the universe the RP is set in, and present themselves consistently with that in mind. Two examples would be my own RPs: first Something Spooky (Something Spooky RP (Sign-Up and Discussion)), and more recently Trial. Site: Alpha (Trial. Site: Alpha (sign-ups and discussion)).
As you might already be able to guess, it’s something that I love doing. It’s a fun challenge to craft something that meets these criteria while still being an effective sign-up sheet, and it seems like it would add an extra level of immersion to the experience. So I’m curious: do people agree with me, or am I just shooting myself in the foot when I try to do that?