Kid A is a weird album for me. I really like about two-thirds of it, but stuff like "Treefingers" just doesn't do it for me at all. I understand it's about textures and creating a mood and not melody, but I just don't enjoy listening to it. And "Optimistic" is a good song, but does it really stand out from stuff by other alt rock bands? I dunno. "How To Disappear Completely" is one of my favorite rock songs ever, though.
That one grows on me a little each time I listen to it. The first few times I thought it was boring, but I'm coming around to think of it as "subtle" instead. It's too much of a downer for me to listen to very much, though.
Yeah, I've tried listening to Pablo Honey a time or two...I think there's a reason why Creep is the only song people still remember.