Haha, what can of worms have I opened?
I really like the discussion that’s been going one here! I have a few thoughts on what’s been said.
First of all, I like the idea of the EPE gathering armies from other planets. I agree that it would be cool to have species of different levels of development with their own strengths and weaknesses. Also the idea that some of those armies don’t actually realize they’re being manipulated is also very cool! Our own history tells us that many of the problems and vices we face have been with us for a long time, whether we recognize it or not.
Something that I don’t quite agree with is the idea that the EPE is the creator of life. The way I see it, EPE just modifies life that already exists. The Bionicle story, especially in its early years, took heavy inspiration from various religions (especially Polynesian religions). Mata Nui is portrayed as a benevolent creator, someone to be revered. One of my favorite moments in the whole story is when the Karzahni plant tells Vakama that the stars tricked Makuta into choosing the correct Toa-Metru. Vakama is filled with relief and gratitude, he realizes that despite all the hardship and reasons to doubt, he and his team did the impossible. He finds out that Mata Nui was not only aware of everything that the Toa Metru did for him, he had chosen them. Through all they did to save the Matoran, they hoped it was the right thing to do, and now Vakama finds out that it was! Vakama’s faith in Mata Nui was not misplaced, it was rewarded. The idea of faith continues in the story with people like Brutaka, who has given up on faith and as such has let his morality corrode.
One of the reasons why I feel like EPE would make a good final antagonist is that doing so takes the themes of the whole story and rather than replacing them, it puts them on a larger scale. Themes of creation and destruction, and especially good v. evil, which is what Makuta represented. To me, going from "we have faith in our creator, to “our creator is a bad guy and we need to be free of him” feels more like a misstep than a subversion. But that’s just me.
For an example of what I would do, lets look at Chrono Trigger. There is some benevolent force of good out there, though we aren’t told specifically who or what. It is guiding our heroes along the way, transcending our concepts of time. This being seems to have bestowed the power of magic upon mankind to benefit them. But those who were given these gifts became selfish, and they separated themselves from those they were supposed to help by building a city in the sky (The Kingdom of Zeal). The leader of the city was not content with these powers, and wanted more. She (Queen Zeal) found an alien source, an apathetic source of destruction (Lavos). She and her city sought to harness it out of pure greed, and they eventually got what they asked for, destruction. From that point on, magic was taken from the earth as a punishment.
To me EPE is like Lavos. The Great Beings and the Element Lords weren’t content with the power they were given, they wanted something stronger. They discovered EP. He’s like a drug. Once they got a bit, they wanted more and more, and would do whatever was necessary to get more. By the end of the story so far, Spherus Magna is supposedly free from this dependency, but the EPE won’t let them break free so easily.
In my opinion, the creator of the Bionicle universe should be a benevolent one, whether we learn a lot about it or not. A bit of mystery keeps the story feeling mystical! After the reveal that Mata Nui was a giant robot, the Matoran Universe lost a lot of its mysticism, since the mysteries were all revealed. The story could have gotten it back by mystifying the Great Beings, but they turned out to be fallible. A lot of people were initially disappointed with that, myself included, but I’ve come to understand that it can work great for the story! But I do think that the overall narrative should keep it’s same mystical quality by reemphasizing the themes used from the very beginning, this time with a larger scale. We’ve gone from the creator of an island, to the creator of the universe! I hope that all makes sense. Thanks for reading all of that!