I understand it to just be the internet at work but that does not mean that everyone needs to be that way.
@StSc
There is no good MOCs or bad MOCs…it is just what different people like. it is a matter of OPINION…so Ghost8o can like it!
See above.
the MOC may look fine to him but not to you. and that is FINE! if he likes it as it is then good for him! he made a good MOC because HE IS HAPPY WITH IT. if you are not then that does not mean his MOC is bad! it just means he likes different things then you.
Okay first off none of my critiques where offensive. It was a friendly argument I was having with Mr. Pot8o
Why are you screaming this at me when I already know it? I gave a critique Pot8o disagreed and I gave an explanation to why I believe I was right.
You Clearly didn’t read my critique. I stated that when proportions are manipulated to give the MOC more character and to project they’re fighting style it works. Similar to how Onua (And gorillas) have weird proportions.
So please stop pointing fingers at people like where devils when you don’t even think about they’re saying.
She looks a tad bit too cluttered. All of the extra armour add-ons and his short limbs give off the impression of a really bunched up look. A good way to fix that without removing any components with be to streamline the colour scheme. Gold is a very strong colour, so replacing that with, let’s say, trans light blue and a white chest piece might serve the moc better.
Proportions are alright, you could make his shins a bit longer, though
Otherwise, solid moc. 8/10. I’m not too crazy about his helmet dealy, and neither am I very fond of his weapons, but he cew.
I will not be continuing this argument so @Ghost8o doesn’t become a argument filled battle ground.
But first I’ll ask you this.
I left my critiques because I wanted this MOC to be as good as it could be so that I could be able to give it a 10/10. That’s always my end goal. I would never give a critique if I didn’t want the creator to be happy.
So I ask you, how where my critiques mean or insulting if my intention was to help a friend?
if I were you, I’d leave the moderating to the mods. you turned the conversation into an argument, with everyone on the same side but you.
your entire argument was pointless here because no one was taking offense.
if you want to defend celtic, do so in his topic.
@Ghost8o,
I actually think the proportions are fine.
the head(mask) looks good
the color balance is out of wack, too much white on the legs, or too much gold on the torso, and if the gold is armour than the layering is messed up on the legs.
otherwise I like it.
Why are you screaming this at me when I already know it? I gave a critique Pot8o disagreed and I gave an explanation to why I believe I was right.